Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Measure of Gratitude

Lewis is a young fellow in Kenya that I email about once a month. Sort of like an old-fashioned pen pal – except he’s a 16-year-old orphan living in the Jerusha Mwiraria Hope Children’s Fund Home in Meru, Kenya, and we contribute to help cover the cost of some of his basic needs.

In a recent email to Lewis, I mentioned our upcoming Thanksgiving Day Holiday – and Lewis asked what the holiday is about and how we celebrate. A simple enough question that got me thinking about what a complicated holiday it really is.

By complicated I don’t mean the challenge of navigating the wild family dynamics around the Thanksgiving dinner table—although watching Aunt Martha’s eccentricities without too much eyerolling, trying to change the subject when Cousin Ralph repeatedly tries to talk about politics, tolerating Grandpa’s fourth retelling of some story, and more can certainly evoke a cry of “serenity now!”

No, I mean the nature of the holiday itself strikes me as complicated

An Experience of Scarcity and Loss

Keeping it simple, I told Lewis that Thanksgiving began a long time ago as a harvest celebration when people gave thanks for having enough food after surviving a very difficult year. “A very difficult year” hardly conveys the true level of loss as the Pilgrims were hit by a perfect storm of bad timing, disease, poor nutrition, inadequate shelter, and exhaustion.

The English immigrants aboard the Mayflower who arrived in November of 1620 in what would become New England were ill-prepared for the conditions they encountered. By the spring of 1621, only 57 of the 102 passengers had survived—with 13 of the 18 adult women on the Mayflower dying during that first winter, leaving only five adult women alive by spring 1621. Additionally, half the Mayflower crew—who always intended to return to England—died during that first winter.

While the Mayflower reached Cape Cod in November, the passengers and crew did not settle at Plymouth until December. The settlers faced a cold, unfamiliar climate and had almost no time to build adequate shelters before the New England winter set in. Many colonists spent weeks and even months living aboard the ship. With few completed houses, many were exposed to freezing temperatures, wind, and damp conditions throughout the winter. Governor William Bradford specifically noted they were "wanting houses and other comforts."

After a voyage lasting more than two months, food supplies were diminished, and the settlers lacked fresh fruits and vegetables. Vitamin C deficiency contributed to scurvy, while poor nutrition in general made people more vulnerable to disease. As the death toll mounted, there were scarcely enough healthy colonists to nurse the ill, bury the dead, and continue building. Bradford recalled that during the worst period only "six or seven" remained strong enough to care for everyone else.

Relying upon the Kindness of Strangers

What's remarkable is that despite losing 45 of the 102 passengers during that first winter, the colony survived. Much of their recovery came from assistance provided by local indigenous peoples. 

Samoset and Squanto

In March 1621, the colonists were astonished when Samoset, an Abenaki man, walked into Plymouth and greeted them in English. Samoset had learned some English from fishermen and traders who regularly visited the region around present-day mid-coast Maine.

Samoset opened the door to communication with neighboring tribes. However, while his English was useful it was also limited. A few days later he returned to Plymouth with Squanto (Tisquantum), a Patuxet man with an extraordinary life story. He had been kidnapped by English traders in 1614, taken to Europe, and eventually returned to New England. Because he spoke English fluently, he became an invaluable interpreter and intermediary between the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag.

Squanto taught the colonists how to survive.  He taught them how to plant corn using fish as fertilizer, which local plants were edible, how to catch eels and fish in local waters, how to find and harvest shellfish., and how to navigate the local environment and seasons. These lessons were critical because the settlers knew little about New England agriculture and ecology.

Alliance with Massasoit

In March 1621, the Wampanoag leader Massasoit negotiated a treaty with Plymouth. The agreement provided mutual defense and relatively peaceful relations for decades, giving the fragile colony time to establish itself. The Wampanoag also shared food, knowledge, and trading relationships that helped the colonists through periods of scarcity. Without those resources, the survivors of the first winter might well have perished.

The story of Plymouth therefore is not simply one of European perseverance. The colony survived because a severely weakened group of settlers received timely assistance, local knowledge, and diplomatic support from Native peoples who understood the land far better than the newcomers did

From Scarcity to Abundance, From Feeling to Action

After a successful harvest in the fall of 1621, the Pilgrims celebrated with a feast of thanksgiving. It is easy to see why. Just months earlier, they had stood on the edge of extinction. Nearly half of their community had died. Food had been scarce. Shelter inadequate. Disease relentless. Yet somehow they had survived.

Gratitude changes how we see the world. It moves us from a mindset of scarcity to an awareness of abundance. When we recognize that we have enough, and perhaps even more than enough, our grip on what we possess naturally begins to loosen.

But the Pilgrims' thanksgiving was about more than relief that they had made it through a difficult year. It was also an acknowledgment of dependence. Their survival had not been achieved alone.

The "First Thanksgiving" was not a gathering of Pilgrims alone. Roughly ninety Wampanoag men, led by Massasoit, participated in the three-day harvest celebration. That means there were substantially more Native Americans than Pilgrims present. In fact, the ninety refers only to Wampanoag men. The historical record does not tell us whether women and children accompanied them, so the Native presence may have been larger still. The familiar image of Pilgrims hosting a handful of Native guests misses a deeper truth. The colony survived because of relationships. It survived because strangers shared knowledge, food, diplomacy, and assistance at a moment when those gifts made the difference between life and death.

Which raises an important question: what is gratitude?

We often think gratitude is a feeling. We feel thankful. We say thank you. We count our blessings.

But gratitude that goes no further than sentiment is incomplete.

True gratitude recognizes that none of us is self-made. Every life is built upon gifts received from others. Parents, teachers, friends, neighbors, mentors, communities, and sometimes complete strangers provide support we could never repay in full.

When we genuinely recognize those gifts, gratitude becomes more than an emotion. It becomes an obligation. Not an obligation to pay back, but to pay forward. 

The ultimate test of gratitude is not what we feel. It is what we do. If gratitude only produces warm feelings, it fades like every other emotion. But when gratitude produces generosity, kindness, hospitality, and concern for others, it becomes a force that changes lives.

Perhaps that is the deepest meaning of Thanksgiving. The holiday is not really about turkey, football, or even remembering a meal in 1621. It is a reminder that every one of us has been helped by people we did not earn, deserve, or even know. And the proper response to such gifts is not merely to be thankful for them. It is to become one of those gifts for someone else.