Wednesday, March 19, 2025

Pilgrims and Puritans


Pilgrims and Puritans:
  A Theocracy in Colonial New England

In 1797, U.S. President John Adams signed the Treaty of Peace and Friendship between the United States of America and the Bey and Subjects of Tripoli of Barbary.  Better known as the Treaty of Tripoli the agreement between the United States and Tripoli (now Libya) was intended to secure commercial shipping rights and to protect American ships in the Mediterranean Sea from Barbary pirates.  But today the treaty is remembered for its Article 11:  The Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion...

The purpose of Article 11 was to assure North African Muslims that the United States was a secular state and that its intentions were not the same as that of earlier Christian nations that took part in the Crusades.  But Article 11 quickly raised dissenting voices.  For instance, Adams's Secretary of War, James McHenry, wrote to the Secretary of the Treasury, Oliver Wolcott, Jr. (1800): 

The Senate … ought never to have ratified the treaty alluded to, with the declaration that “the government of the United States, is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion.” What else is it founded on? This act always appeared to me like trampling upon the cross.

This contemporary-sounding argument over the founding nature of the United States began with the ink barely dry on the U.S. Constitution’s amendment prohibiting Congress from passing any legislation “respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…”

The notions of secular government and freedom of religion were novel in the 18th century—and not generally accepted by either the European nations or the British colonies in North America.  National identity, patriotic loyalty, and unity were thought to be achieved and maintained only through conformity of thought and behavior as defined by the ruler.  The idea that individuals have a right to their own thoughts and beliefs was subversive, treasonous, and a threat to national security.  

Consequently, each of the British colonies in North America attempted to enforce strict religious observance through both colonial governments and local town rules.  Most of the colonies had established churches with the salaries of ministers of those established churches paid through taxation.  The colonies also had some sort of religious test requirement for officeholders.  Strict limits were place on members of other churches, including prohibitions on their public religious services and at times even prohibiting them from even entering the colony.  Virginia, for instance, banned the public celebration of the Catholic Mass until Catholic soldiers from France arrived to fight in the American Revolution.  Nowhere in the colonies were state and church more enmeshed than in New England, the land of the Pilgrims and the Puritans—and their spiritual heirs, the Congregationalists—who envisioned building a Protestant Christian theocracy in the New World. 

As usual, my plan for this series is to take the long view on the history of the relationship between government and religion.  Starting with some ancient history, we will work our way up to the questions of who were the Pilgrims and Puritans, what was the basis for their vision of a North American Protestant Christian theocracy, and what did they do about it when they got to New England?  And then we grapple with the novel thinking some of America’s founders like of Thomas Jefferson and James Madison that turned a rebellion into a revolution—and thwarted the Pilgrim and Puritan ambitions for a Calvinist theocracy. 

"Swing Heil" - Even Dancing Can Be An Act of Courage

Have you seen the film Swing Kids ?  Not the 2018 film set in Geoje POW camp during the Korean War in 1951.  I mean the 1993 film set in Ham...